Nutmeg Shortbread

POSTED IN : Recipe Sunday

Why do you cook?

To remind you of home? To experiment with a new ingredient? To release your creativity? To relax?

I’ve been posting Recipe Sundays for a few years now as a casual thing I do for our bloggy-blog, and even though I’ve always known that I am probably the last person on earth to be talking about cooking (I don’t have a minute of formal training or an ounce of technical skill), I’ve always enjoyed it. When Jeff and I got married, I couldn’t even make scrambled eggs. I had Hamburger Helper lining the pantry shelves with boxes of cereal and Hot Pockets as go-to snacks. Thankfully, I’ve come a long way since then, and our pantry seems a bit more…well…developed.

I don’t know why, but when I was kneading this Nutmeg Shortbread for this post, I realized why I love to cook. Not because I’m great at it (far from it actually) but because I’m a quiet, shy, in-the-background, farm girl that loves by hosting. During any party, I would much rather be in the kitchen or behind the scenes making sure everything is ready than mingling through the crowd. When I set a plate or a drink or a dish in front of a guest or a family member, I’m placing my heart right down in front of them. I’m exposed and vulnerable, hoping that they feel welcomed by the delicious smells in front of them and the time it took to produce them.

I can’t explain it, but this Nutmeg Shortbread embodies all that I love about cooking. It reminds me of home – how my mom would bake the leftover pie crust on a baking sheet sprinkled with cinnamon and sugar. A flaky treat that I looked forward to more than the pies. In fact, I baked this shortbread in my grandmother’s pie pan – she was an avid baker and pie-baking is a must-have skill in my family.

So I cook in order to show my love, and there’s something about the smell of nutmeg that embodies a kitchen and all that it represents. The ease of this dessert especially is like throwing together a quick hug – just a few simple ingredients that, when combined, produce a loving welcome.

You’ll need flour, sugar, butter, egg yolk, and nutmeg. Like I said, simple yet wonderful.


Mix together your flour and nutmeg first.

002 003

Then add in the chunks of butter and rub them in with your hands until the entire thing feels like sand – small and grainy.

005 006

Then mix in the sugar completely before adding the egg yolk. Then you’ll be able to press it together into a loose dough. Knead the dough a dozen times on a work surface and then press it into a metal cake or pie pan.

007 008

Poke a bunch of holes in the surface using a fork and sprinkle with nutmeg and sugar.

009 010

Bake for about 50 minutes in the oven until it turns golden then let it cool in the pan on a rack. For such a long bake time, it’s a truly simple prep.

011 012

This is a mouthwatering, buttery treat that says “I love you” with every single bite – a new tasty staple at Casa de Youngren.

Nutmeg Shortbread

(view original recipe from Food & Wine)

  • 1 1/3 cups flour
  • 1 teaspoon grated nutmeg
  • 1/4 pound cold unsalted butter, cut into 1/4-inch cubes
  • 6 tablespoons sugar
  • 1 large egg yolk


  1. Heat the oven to 325°. Butter an 8-inch round metal cake or pie pan.
  2. In a medium bowl, whisk together the flour and 3/4 teaspoon of the nutmeg. With your fingers, rub in the butter completely until the mixture is the texture of sand. Using a fork, stir in 5 tablespoons of the sugar. Stir in the egg yolk. Press the mixture together to make a dry, crumbly dough and put it on a work surface. Knead the dough about twelve times until it just holds together.
  3. Press the dough in an even layer into the prepared pan. With a small, sharp knife, mark eight wedges halfway into the dough. With a fork, prick the dough every 1/2 inch or so. In a small bowl, combine the remaining 1 tablespoon sugar and 1/4 teaspoon nutmeg and sprinkle it on the dough. Bake the shortbread in the middle of the oven until golden, 50 to 55 minutes.
  4. Let the shortbread cool slightly in the pan set on a rack and then cut into wedges. Let cool completely in the pan.


Welcome! We’re Jeff & Erin.

It’s our job to help you slow down and experience every moment of your wedding day – because we believe that it should be savored from top to bottom.

We’re Jeff & Erin Youngren, a hubby & wifey wedding photography team that believes timeless trumps trendy, life is best done together, and tears, hugs, & high fives should never be held back.

We consider our couples part of our family – and we cannot wait to meet you!

Start Here


About Us

We're Jeff & Erin

We’re Jeff and Erin Youngren, and we believe running a business should be life-giving (not soul-sucking). So we’re passionate about teaching other photographers to run life-giving businesses and book clients they absolutely love.  

For 15 years, we’ve photographed weddings all over the world as a hubby & wifey team, but we’ve also grown a multi-brand photography studio in San Diego, CA. 

New Here? Start with these posts!